CellariusHoroscope
EN-GBEnglish (UK)

Sailing by the stars

Longitude: the States General, Galileo and Huygens

How far north or south you are, you can read from the sky. How far east or west you are is a matter of time: one hour of difference is 15 degrees. The Dutch Republic offered a prize for it in 1600, Galileo offered the States General the moons of Jupiter in 1636, and Huygens had his pendulum clocks tested on Dutch East India Company ships.

Why longitude was so hard

For latitude, you need one measurement: the height of the noon Sun or of the Pole Star, with a table. For longitude, you need to know what time it is at home at the moment it is noon where you are. Earth turns once in 24 hours, so every hour of difference is 15 degrees; at the equator a degree is about 111 kilometres. Anyone without the time from home sailed by dead reckoning: course, speed and time elapsed.

home 12:00ship 13:0015°
Seen from above the North Pole. Earth turns counterclockwise. If it is 1 p.m. on the ship when it is noon at home, the ship is 15° farther east. Our own drawing.

The prizes

Spain was the first to offer a reward: Philip II offered six thousand ducats in 1567, and in 1598 Philip III added a life annuity of two thousand ducats. On 1 April 1600, the States General promised whoever brought the solution five thousand guilders in cash and a thousand pounds a year. That Dutch pound was worth twenty stuivers, the same as a guilder, so it came to a thousand guilders a year. According to Richard de Grijs, the prize was raised in 1611 to at most 15,000 guilders and in 1660 to 25,000 guilders. England followed only in 1714.

The first Dutch hope was the compass. Petrus Plancius believed that the variation of the compass needle followed a fixed pattern, so that you could read longitude from the variation and your latitude; Reynier Pietersz. van Twisch of Hoorn made an instrument for it. That story is on our page about the golden compass.

Galileo and the States General (1636–1637)

In a letter of 15 August 1636, Galileo Galilei offered the States General his method: the moons of Jupiter as a clock in the sky, with his tables, his better telescopes and a timekeeper. On 11 November 1636, Laurens Reael, a former governor-general of the Indies, brought the proposal and a translation to the assembly. The States set up a committee: Reael himself, the astronomer Martinus Hortensius and the mapmaker Willem Blaeu. Professor Golius was to join them, but his place soon went to Isaac Beeckman.

The committee saw the objections. Hortensius wrote in January 1637 that there were no telescopes in the Republic sharp enough, and that the tables had to be right at least a year ahead. Even so, on 20 April 1637, the States decided to honour Galileo ‘met een gouden kettingh ter waerde van vyffhondert gulden’ (with a gold chain worth five hundred guilders), to have the method studied further, and to have the East India Company give Reael a thousand guilders for instruments.

No final verdict came. Beeckman died in May 1637, Reael in October 1637, Blaeu in October 1638 and Hortensius in August 1639. Galileo himself died on 8 January 1642.

The moons of Jupiter as a clock

Galileo’s idea: the four large moons of Jupiter move so regularly that you can put their positions in a table in advance, in home time. What you see at Jupiter, you see everywhere on Earth at the same moment. If at sea you see, at nine in the evening local time, a configuration that the table puts at ten o’clock at home, your ship is one hour, so 15 degrees, west of home.

On a ship it did not work. You have to follow the small moons through a telescope on a rolling deck; for that, Galileo designed a chair in a double basin of oil in 1637. And the tables had to be very accurate. So the search went on for a clock that could carry the time from home.

Huygens and the pendulum clock at sea

Christiaan Huygens received a patent for his pendulum clock in 1657 and was already thinking about longitude at sea that year. In January 1663, the Scot Alexander Bruce took two clocks made by Severijn Oosterwijck, a clockmaker in The Hague, to England. It went wrong: one fell over in the rolling of the ship, the other simply stopped. Captain Robert Holmes sailed with two clocks to Portugal in 1663, with a fair result, and then to Guinea. His report appeared in the Philosophical Transactions in March 1665. That same month, Samuel Pepys told the Royal Society that the ship’s master said ordinary dead reckoning had come as close to the truth as the clocks.

The States of Holland granted Huygens a patent for his marine clock on 16 December 1664. In 1665, he wrote a manual for navigators: the Kort onderwijs aengaende het gebruyck der horologien tot het vinden der lenghten van Oost en West (Short instruction on the use of clocks for finding longitude).

The big test came from the Dutch East India Company. At the end of 1682, Johannes Hudde received up to two thousand guilders for the clocks. In 1685, Huygens himself sailed on a small vessel from Amsterdam to Texel; he got seasick, one clock ran well and the other kept stopping. In May 1686, two clocks went with the Huis te Zilverstein to the Cape, with Thomas Helder, Johannes de Graaff and the clockmaker Van der Dussen. On the return voyage on the Wapen van Alcmaer (from the Cape on 20 April 1687, at Texel on 15 August), Helder died, and De Graaff carried on the measurements.

Huygens worked through the numbers and found that a pendulum runs differently at a different latitude. After that correction, according to his report of 24 April 1688, the clock came out about 19 kilometres east of Texel. Burchard de Volder called the test a success on balance in 1689, but the results were so close to dead reckoning that it was impossible to say which method was better. The second test, with the Brandenburgh, which sailed on 30 December 1690, and came back in October 1692, failed: the clocks kept stopping and a spring broke. In 1693 Huygens accepted that it had not worked.

And then Harrison

The problem was solved in England, with a clock without a pendulum. John Harrison worked from 1740 for nineteen years on his third marine clock; his fourth, the H4, is a large watch that ticks five times a second. The Board of Longitude decided to pay him £7,500 once he explained how his timekeeper was built.

What does a clock that drifts cost?

A clock set at home runs a little fast or slow at sea. Enter how many seconds a day, how long the voyage lasts and at what latitude you sail.

After 42 days the clock is 3.5 minutes off. That is 52.5 minutes of arc in longitude, or about 91.4 km east or west at 20° latitude.

The rule: Earth turns 360° in 24 hours, so 4 seconds of time is 1 minute of arc in longitude; a minute of arc in longitude is 1.852 km times the cosine of the latitude. Our own calculator; the calculation runs in your browser.

What we don’t know

  • Why Galileo did not accept the gold chain. According to the Galileo Project at Rice University, the Inquisition forbade it; according to de Grijs, the pope did. The resolution of 1637 that we read mentions only the decision to give a chain; some sources speak of a crown or a medal, but neither is in it.
  • Whether Holmes’s test really went as well as he wrote. Pepys heard doubts as early as 1665, and the clocks disagreed with one another.
  • We know the increases of the prize in 1611 and 1660 only from de Grijs; we have not read the decisions themselves.

Sources

  • C. de Waard (ed.), Journal tenu par Isaac Beeckman, vol. 4 (1953): the resolutions of the States General and the letters about Galileo, 1636–1637 (DBNL). dbnl.org
  • R. de Grijs, ‘European Longitude Prizes. 2: Astronomy, religion and engineering solutions in the Dutch Republic,’ Journal of Astronomical History and Heritage 24 (2021), 405–439 (arXiv version): the prize of 1600 and its increases, the East India Company tests. arxiv.org
  • R. Higgitt, on the longitude prizes, in the Encyclopaedia of the History of Science: the Spanish prizes and the prize of the States General. ethos.lps.library.cmu.edu
  • Christiaan Huygens, Oeuvres complètes, vol. 17 (1932): the introduction to and the text of the Kort onderwijs, with Bruce, Holmes and Pepys (DBNL). dbnl.org
  • A. van der Kraan, ‘The Dutch East India Company, Christiaan Huygens and the Marine Clock, 1682–95,’ Prometheus 19 (2001): the East India Company tests. doi.org
  • M. Bennett et al., ‘Huygens’s clocks,’ Proceedings of the Royal Society A 458 (2002), 563–579: the tests of 1662–1665. doi.org
  • The Galileo Project (Rice University), ‘Longitude’: Galileo and the States General. galileo.library.rice.edu
  • Royal Museums Greenwich, Board of Longitude (archive object 478820): the £7,500 for Harrison. rmg.co.uk
  • Royal Museums Greenwich, on Harrison’s clocks and the longitude problem: H3 and H4. rmg.co.uk

More

Enjoyed this? Buy me a coffee ☕